🔍 Read the full analysis: What AI Brings To Spreadsheets Used By Bookkeepers on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
TL;DR
Spreadsheets and accounting software have reduced the time spent on routine bookkeeping, while U.S. employment has shifted toward a roughly equal number of bookkeeping clerks and accountants. The source says the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects further clerk-job decline and accountant growth through 2035, but those are forecasts; it provides no measured evidence of AI’s current effect on bookkeeping employment.
A November 22 report on ThorstenMeyerAI.com argues that spreadsheets and accounting software have reduced the time needed for routine bookkeeping, while U.S. employment has shifted from roughly two bookkeeping clerks per accountant to about one of each in 2025. It frames AI as the next potential source of automation, but the figures it cites do not measure AI’s current effect on jobs: the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ projections are forecasts, not confirmed outcomes.
The report traces the spreadsheet’s appeal to a basic change in workflow: when a figure changed, linked calculations could update automatically. It recounts how Dan Bricklin conceived the idea while studying a financial case at Harvard Business School in 1978, then worked with programmer Bob Frankston on VisiCalc. Bricklin said the first complete VisiCalc package shipped for the Apple II on October 19, 1979. The program let users change an input and recalculate dependent values on a screen-based grid.
The report illustrates the time savings with an account from journalist Steven Levy’s 1984 article in Harper’s. Cincinnati accountant Don Jackson, who served 40 to 50 clients, said a financial what-if that could take 20 hours by hand took him 15 minutes with a spreadsheet. That is an individual example, not a measure of average productivity across the profession. The report also notes that computerized bookkeeping predated personal spreadsheets: German tax advisers founded DATEV in 1966 to process clients’ books using mainframes.
Employment figures cited in the report show a long-term shift in the relative size of the occupations. It gives BLS counts of about 2.25 million bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks in 1988, compared with roughly 963,000 accountants and auditors. For 2025, it cites about 1.53 million clerks and 1.60 million accountants and auditors. The figures describe job counts, not the cause of the change; the report says spreadsheets were not the only factor and points to accounting software taking over posting and addition.
Infographic 01 · How the spreadsheet arrived
From the abacus to VisiCalc
Machines chased bookkeeping for decades. The spreadsheet put the calculation on every desk.
Machines and the books
- Tokyo, November 1946: an American soldier with an electric calculator against a Japanese postal worker with a soroban. The abacus won four rounds out of five (Computer History Museum).
- Nuremberg, 14 February 1966: 65 tax advisers found DATEV to do their clients’ bookkeeping by computer; the first data centre had four rented IBM mainframes at DM 245,000 a month (DATEV).
- Spring 1978: Harvard Business School student Dan Bricklin imagines a calculator that redoes a ledger sheet by itself (Bricklin).
- October 1979: VisiCalc by Bricklin and Bob Frankston ships for the Apple II. The analyst Ben Rosen: “the software tail that wags (and sells) the personal computer dog.”
- Early 1983: Lotus 1-2-3 for the IBM PC; it soon replaces VisiCalc as the leading spreadsheet (Bricklin).
- 1984: more than a million spreadsheet programs a year in the US. Levy warns: even an elegant spreadsheet is “a house of cards”.
Company and personal accounts are marked as such. The 20-hours figure is one accountant’s own account, as reported by Steven Levy.
Sources: D. Bricklin, VisiCalc history; S. Levy, Harper's, November 1984; Computer History Museum; DATEV company history.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
How Automation Reshaped Accounting Work
The history matters because it separates automating tasks from eliminating an occupation. Spreadsheets made calculations and scenario testing faster, while accounting software handled some routine recording and adding. The report’s account suggests that workers’ tasks and the balance between job categories changed over decades; it does not establish that spreadsheets alone caused the employment shift.
For bookkeepers and small businesses, the distinction is practical. If software handles more repetitive entry and calculations, people may spend less time on those tasks, but the figures here do not show how much time AI currently saves, how widely specific tools are used, or whether savings have changed staffing at individual firms. The report says about 1.5 million clerk jobs remained in 2025, a reminder that automation did not make the occupation disappear.
The report cites BLS projections of a 6% decline in clerk employment by 2035 and 5% growth for accountants and auditors. Those forecasts signal an expected difference in direction, not a certain result or a specific estimate of AI’s contribution. They matter to workers, employers and training providers, but should not be read as proof that AI has already caused either trend.
Products Worth Considering

DJI Mini 3 Drone with DJI RC Controller

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Wireless Noise-Cancelling Over-Ear Headphones with Spatial Audio, White Smoke

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Bluetooth Noise-Cancelling Headphones, Ice Blue
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Ledger Sheets to VisiCalc
Before personal spreadsheets, a business could use paper ledgers and hand calculators, while large-scale computer processing was available through specialist-run systems. The report describes spreadsheet software as bringing recalculation onto a personal computer, where a user could change an assumption without rewriting an entire sheet. That made financial modelling more accessible to accountants and managers, alongside its use for bookkeeping.
VisiCalc was followed by Lotus 1-2-3 for IBM PCs in 1983, which the report says soon replaced it as the leading spreadsheet. Levy reported in 1984 that Americans were buying more than a million spreadsheet programs a year, worth more than $250 million, and that VisiCalc had sold more than 700,000 copies. These figures provide a snapshot of early adoption, not a measure of current spreadsheet use or employment impact.
The report places today’s AI discussion within that longer history of tools changing accounting tasks. It does not provide a new survey, employer case study or independent evaluation of AI products. Its central evidence is historical reporting, employment counts and BLS projections.
What the Employment Figures Cannot Show
The figures in the report show that the number of clerks and the number of accountants changed over time, but they do not isolate the effects of spreadsheets, accounting software, economic conditions, changes in business activity or other technologies. The historical comparison is not proof of a single cause. Nor does a change in occupational counts reveal what happened to individual workers or their duties.
The source gives no current adoption data for AI tools in bookkeeping, no estimate of tasks already automated by AI, and no comparison of productivity or staffing at firms using those tools. The BLS numbers for 2035 are projections; actual employment may differ. The report also does not explain the methods behind every cited employment total, so readers should treat them as figures reported from BLS sources rather than as a fresh analysis of the underlying data.
How AI’s Job Effects Will Be Measured
The next evidence to watch is whether later employment data and workplace research show changes consistent with the BLS forecasts. Current job counts alone will not establish whether AI caused a shift; useful evidence would also track which bookkeeping tasks firms automate, how workers’ responsibilities change and whether staffing changes follow.
For now, the report’s clearest conclusion is historical: spreadsheet and accounting tools changed how financial work could be done, while bookkeeping employment continued at substantial scale. The scale and employment effect of AI in the field remain unsettled, and the projections should be treated as expectations rather than results.
Key Questions
Did spreadsheets eliminate bookkeeping jobs?
The report does not say they eliminated the occupation. It says routine work changed, clerical employment fell over time, and about 1.53 million bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerk jobs remained in 2025. It also says accounting software, not spreadsheets alone, took over some tasks.
What did a spreadsheet change for accountants?
A spreadsheet could recalculate linked figures after a user changed an input, instead of requiring each figure to be recomputed by hand. One accountant quoted in a 1984 Harper’s article said a particular what-if calculation went from 20 hours to 15 minutes; that is an individual example.
What does the report say about AI and jobs?
It cites BLS projections of a 6% decline in bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerk employment by 2035 and 5% growth for accountants and auditors. These are forecasts, not confirmed outcomes, and the source does not quantify AI’s contribution.
How many clerks and accountants were employed in 2025?
The report cites about 1.53 million bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks and about 1.60 million accountants and auditors in 2025. Those counts describe the occupations; they do not identify what caused their relative sizes to change.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
